Island City House Hotel – Key West Resort Review
Last updated: August 28, 2026
Choose Island City House Hotel if...
- You want apartment-style suites with kitchenettes for an extended stay
- You're a couple wanting quiet historic garden charm in Old Town
- You want a walkable William Street location near the Historic Seaport and Duval
Skip Island City House Hotel if...
- You want ocean views or waterfront access — there's none on-site
- You expect full-service resort amenities like a spa, room service, or concierge desk
- You're traveling with young children seeking kid-specific activities or programs
AskTheKeys Traveler Match
How well does Island City House Hotel fit your trip?
Before you book — the one trade-off
Island City House is a quiet garden guest house with no waterfront or resort amenities — you trade ocean views and full service for kitchenette suites in historic Old Town.
AskTheKeys Decision SummaryIsland City House Hotel is best for groups and couples wanting apartment-style suites with kitchenettes in a lush tropical garden setting in the heart of Old Town. It is not ideal for guests seeking ocean views or full-service resort amenities, as this is a charming historic guest house without waterfront access.
Island City House is a historic guest house on William Street in Old Town, offering apartment-style suites with kitchenettes set around a lush tropical garden and pool. It is ideal for extended stays and couples who prefer quiet charm over resort-scale amenities. There is no waterfront access.
Compare current room availability and secure member-only pricing.
We handle our lodging checks through Expedia's network engine so you can lock in hidden seasonal discounts and stack your One Key™ rewards points across different island brands.
Before You Book
The details that matter after you've narrowed down your options.
Best for
- Couples
- Extended Stays
- Quiet
- History
Not ideal for
- Guests expecting full-service resort amenities like a spa, room service, or concierge desk — this is a charming guest house, not a large resort
- Families with young children seeking kid-specific activities, large pools, or supervised programs
Quick facts
| Address | 411 William St, Key West, FL 33040 |
|---|---|
| Phone | +13052945702 |
| Check-in / Out | 4:00 PM / 11:00 AM |
| Parking | Available |
| Pets | No |
| Beach access | No |
| Pool(s) | Yes |
| Spa | No |
| EV charging | Unknown |
Location & nearby
Island City House Hotel is located in Old Town – William Street / Historic Seaport within Key West.
What's nearby
- Sloppy Joe's Bar(0.2 mi, 4 min walk)
- Mel Fisher Maritime Museum(0.2 mi, 5 min walk)
- Harry S. Truman Little White House(0.3 mi, 5 min walk)
- Key West Seaport & Historic Bight(0.3 mi, 5 min walk)
- Key West Cemetery(0.3 mi, 6 min walk)
- Dry Tortugas Ferry Terminal(0.3 mi, 6 min walk)
- Custom House Museum(0.3 mi, 7 min walk)
- Audubon House & Tropical Gardens(0.3 mi, 6 min walk)
Amenities overview
Property highlight features
- Pool
- Gardens
- Kitchenettes
- Bikes
Pricing positioning
Typical nightly pricing tends to fall in the $$ range, depending on season and room type.
$$
Compare current room availability and secure member-only pricing.
We handle our lodging checks through Expedia's network engine so you can lock in hidden seasonal discounts and stack your One Key™ rewards points across different island brands.
Independent Decision Engine
Florida Keys Resorts operates as a fully objective, crowdsourced review system. We do not accept paid placements from hotels to alter their scoring records. Instead, we use standardized API connections to provide transparent third-party rate checks for our community.
How Island City House Hotel Compares to Other Key West Resorts
Island City House Hotel vs Curry Mansion Inn
- Island City House Hotel wins:Apartment-style suites with kitchenettes ideal for longer stays and self-catering
- Curry Mansion Inn wins:Complimentary cooked breakfast and daily cocktail happy hour included in rate
Island City House Hotel vs The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
- Island City House Hotel wins:Quieter garden setting with more space and privacy in suite-style rooms
- The Marker Key West Harbor Resort wins:Modern luxury with three pools, on-site restaurant, and harbor views
Island City House Hotel vs Pier House Resort & Spa
- Island City House Hotel wins:More affordable with kitchenettes, garden privacy, and a residential feel
- Pier House Resort & Spa wins:Full-service resort with spa, private beach, and waterfront dining on the harbor
Island City House Hotel vs Westwinds Inn
- Island City House Hotel wins:multi-building historic compound with tropical gardens, pool, and suite variety
- Westwinds Inn wins:compact boutique inn with intimate Old Town character and Riley collection backing
FAQs
Are the rooms apartment-style?
Yes, most suites feature kitchenettes or full kitchens, making it great for longer stays.
Does Island City House provide bicycles?
Yes, complimentary bicycles are available for guests to explore Old Town Key West and the surrounding area.
Is Island City House Hotel in Old Town?
Yes, it is located on William Street in the Historic Seaport District, within walking distance of Duval Street and the harbor.
How old is Island City House Hotel?
Island City House is the oldest continuously operating guest house in Key West, with roots dating back to the 1880s. The property spans three historic buildings surrounded by tropical gardens.
Is there a pool at Island City House?
Yes, the hotel has a courtyard swimming pool set among lush tropical gardens, offering a private and relaxing atmosphere.
Is Island City House good for extended stays?
Yes, the apartment-style suites with kitchenettes make it one of the best options in Key West for stays of a week or longer. Many guests use it as a home base for exploring the island.
Is there parking at Island City House?
Limited parking is available on a first-come, first-served basis. In Old Town Key West, walking and biking are the preferred ways to get around.
Is Island City House Hotel quiet?
Yes, despite being steps from Duval Street, the property is tucked away in a garden setting that feels removed from the bustle. It is one of the quietest places to stay in Old Town.