Coconut Cay Resort & Marina – Marathon Resort Review
Last updated: August 28, 2026
Choose Coconut Cay Resort & Marina if...
- You're a boater or angler wanting marina dockage at a mid-range boutique property
- You prefer kitchenette suites and casual self-service over resort programming
- You're a couple wanting a quiet waterfront pool without the bustle of a big resort
Skip Coconut Cay Resort & Marina if...
- You want luxury — Coconut Cay is a boutique marina resort, not full-service
- You want a beach — it's on the harbor; Sombrero Beach is 2.5 miles away
- You expect full-service dining, spa, or organized activities
AskTheKeys Traveler Match
How well does Coconut Cay Resort & Marina fit your trip?
Before you book — the one trade-off
Coconut Cay keeps it small and casual — you get a marina, pool, and kitchenettes at a fair price, but no beach or full-service resort amenities.
AskTheKeys Decision SummaryCoconut Cay Resort & Marina is best for boaters, anglers, and independent travelers wanting a smaller boutique marina resort with kitchenette suites, waterfront pool, and casual Keys atmosphere in Marathon. It is not ideal for luxury seekers, beach seekers, or guests wanting full-service resort amenities.
Choose Coconut Cay if you want a small, casual marina resort with kitchenette suites and a waterfront pool. Skip it if you need a beach or full-service amenities.
Compare current room availability and secure member-only pricing.
We handle our lodging checks through Expedia's network engine so you can lock in hidden seasonal discounts and stack your One Key™ rewards points across different island brands.
Before You Book
The details that matter after you've narrowed down your options.
Best for
- Boaters and anglers who want marina dockage and fishing access at a mid-range boutique property
- Independent travelers who prefer kitchenette suites and casual self-service over resort programming
- Pet owners seeking a pet-friendly marina property with waterfront outdoor space
- Couples wanting a quiet waterfront pool setting without the scale and bustle of a large resort
Not ideal for
- Luxury seekers — Coconut Cay is a boutique marina resort, not a full-service luxury property
- Beach seekers — the resort is on the harbor; nearest public beach is Sombrero Beach (2.5 miles)
Quick facts
| Address | 7196 Overseas Highway, Marathon, FL 33050 |
|---|---|
| Phone | (305) 289-7672 |
| Check-in / Out | 3:00 PM / 11:00 AM |
| Parking | On-site (free) |
| Pets | Yes (fee may apply) |
| Beach access | No |
| Pool(s) | Yes |
| Spa | No |
| EV charging | No |
Location & nearby
Coconut Cay Resort & Marina is located in Marathon within Marathon.
What's nearby
- Crane Point Museum & Nature Center(1 mi, 20 min walk)
- Sombrero Beach(2.5 mi, 50 min walk)
- Turtle Hospital(2 mi, 40 min walk)
- Keys Fisheries Market & Marina(1.5 mi, 30 min walk)
- Marathon Community Park(1.8 mi, 36 min walk)
- Seven Mile Bridge(5 mi, 100 min walk)
- Pigeon Key(6 mi, 120 min walk)
- Bahia Honda State Park(16 mi, 320 min walk)
Amenities overview
Property highlight features
- Marina with boat dockage and fishing access
- Kitchenette suites and efficiencies
- Waterfront pool with harbor views
- Pet-friendly accommodations
- Casual Keys atmosphere with personal service
Pricing positioning
Typical nightly pricing tends to fall in the $$ range, depending on season and room type.
mid-range boutique marina resort
Compare current room availability and secure member-only pricing.
We handle our lodging checks through Expedia's network engine so you can lock in hidden seasonal discounts and stack your One Key™ rewards points across different island brands.
Independent Decision Engine
Florida Keys Resorts operates as a fully objective, crowdsourced review system. We do not accept paid placements from hotels to alter their scoring records. Instead, we use standardized API connections to provide transparent third-party rate checks for our community.
How Coconut Cay Resort & Marina Compares to Other Marathon Resorts
Coconut Cay Resort & Marina vs Captain Pip's Marina & Hideaway
- Coconut Cay Resort & Marina wins:boutique marina resort with kitchenettes, pool, and slightly more polished amenities
- Captain Pip's Marina & Hideaway wins:casual marina hideaway with budget pricing, bare-bones charm, and raw boating authenticity
Coconut Cay Resort & Marina vs Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club
- Coconut Cay Resort & Marina wins:intimate boutique marina with kitchenettes, casual atmosphere, and lower price point
- Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club wins:larger yacht club resort with waterfront restaurant, fitness center, and more expansive facilities
Coconut Cay Resort & Marina vs Indigo Reef Resort Villas & Marina
- Coconut Cay Resort & Marina wins:compact marina resort with kitchenette suites and casual boating-focused atmosphere
- Indigo Reef Resort Villas & Marina wins:villa resort with full kitchens, multi-bedroom units, and more spacious self-catering layout
FAQs
Does Coconut Cay have a marina?
Yes. Coconut Cay Resort & Marina offers boat dockage and marina access, providing a convenient base for boating, fishing, and snorkeling in the Middle Keys. Dockage availability varies and should be confirmed at booking.
Does Coconut Cay have a pool?
Yes. Coconut Cay has a waterfront outdoor pool with a sun deck overlooking the harbor. The pool area is the main communal space and provides sunset views over the water.
Is Coconut Cay pet-friendly?
Yes. Coconut Cay welcomes pets in designated rooms for an additional fee. The waterfront grounds and marina setting provide outdoor walking areas for pet owners.
Does Coconut Cay have a restaurant?
No. Coconut Cay does not have an on-site restaurant. Kitchenette suites allow basic meal preparation. Nearby dining includes Keys Fisheries Market & Marina (1.5 miles) and several restaurants along the Overseas Highway in Marathon.
What types of rooms does Coconut Cay offer?
Coconut Cay offers kitchenette suites and efficiency units, most with small kitchens or kitchenettes equipped with microwave, mini-fridge, and basic cooking tools. Some units have waterfront views and private patios.
How does Coconut Cay compare to Faro Blanco?
Coconut Cay is smaller, more intimate, and less expensive than Faro Blanco Resort & Yacht Club. Faro Blanco offers a waterfront restaurant, fitness center, and yacht club amenities. Coconut Cay offers a quieter, more casual marina experience with kitchenette suites.
How far is Coconut Cay from Sombrero Beach?
Sombrero Beach is approximately 2.5 miles from Coconut Cay, about a 7-minute drive. Sombrero Beach is Marathon's most popular public sand beach with picnic areas and shallow water.
Do you need a car at Coconut Cay?
Yes. Marathon is car-dependent for groceries, dining, and attractions. Coconut Cay provides free on-site parking. The kitchenettes reduce dining trips, but a car is essential for any off-property activity.