Best Resorts in Key Largo Florida

Playa Largo is the flagship resort of Key Largo — the largest and most full-service property in the region. It has multiple restaurants, a spa, two pools, a private beach area, and water sports. It is the closest thing to a traditional resort experience in Key Largo. Best for travelers who want resort amenities alongside reef access.

Baker's Cay is set within a natural hardwood hammock — a rare coastal forest ecosystem. It is quieter and more nature-focused than Playa Largo, with a more relaxed pace and fewer crowds. The design emphasizes the natural surroundings rather than traditional resort amenities. Best for couples and nature lovers who want an upscale but understated stay.

Amoray is the only resort in Key Largo with an on-site PADI dive operator. It is purpose-built for divers and snorkelers — the rooms are functional, but the dive access is the point. Daily reef trips, dive packages, and equipment rental are all on-site. Best for divers who care more about reef access than room quality.

Reefhouse is a marina-focused resort with on-site boat slips, making it the best choice for travelers who bring their own boat or want easy water access. It combines marina functionality with dive proximity — a solid middle ground between a dive resort and a boating base. Best for boaters and divers who want marina convenience.

Kona Kai is the most unique boutique property in Key Largo — a small resort with a private beach, botanical gardens, and an on-site art gallery. It has a 14+ age policy (not adults-only, but no young children), creating a quieter atmosphere. Best for couples and travelers who want a peaceful, distinctive stay with beach access.

Marina Del Mar is the most affordable marina resort in Key Largo. It has an old Keys vibe — simple, functional, and waterfront. The marina is the main draw, with boat access and a laid-back atmosphere. Rooms are basic but clean. Best for budget travelers and boaters who want waterfront access without paying luxury prices.

Ocean Pointe offers condo-style suites with full kitchens, making it ideal for extended stays and families who want to cook. Located at MM 92.5 in Tavernier (technically the southernmost edge of the Key Largo cluster), it has a fishing pier and pool. Best for families and longer stays where kitchen access matters.

Waterside Suites is a mid-tier marina property with suite-style rooms and boat access. It sits between the budget options (Marina Del Mar) and the luxury tier (Playa Largo), offering a practical marina base with more space than a standard hotel room. Best for travelers who want marina access at a mid-range price.

Dolphin Point offers standalone villa units for travelers who want privacy and independence. There is no front desk or resort structure — you manage your own stay. Best for self-directed travelers and couples who prefer a private, quiet setting over a managed resort experience.

The Courtyard is the Marriott Bonvoy option in Key Largo — reliable, predictable, and earns/burns points. It lacks the character of independent properties but delivers consistent quality. Best for Bonvoy members, business travelers, and anyone who values chain hotel reliability.

Seafarer is one of the few Key Largo properties with beach access at a budget price point. It is simple and no-frills, but the waterfront setting and low price make it one of the best value stays in the region. Best for budget travelers who want beach access without paying resort prices.

Anchorage is a yacht club and residential-style marina property. It appeals to boaters and travelers who want a more residential feel than a traditional hotel. The marina is the focus, and the atmosphere is quiet and community-oriented. Best for yacht owners and travelers who want a marina-forward stay.