Best Resorts in the Florida Keys
Luxury, boutique, beach, marina, family, and adults-only — the strongest resorts in each category across all five regions
The Florida Keys have over 100 resorts across five regions, and the "best" depends entirely on what you are looking for. Little Palm Island is the luxury pinnacle. Isla Bella has the best beach. Hawks Cay is strongest for families. The Gardens Hotel is the boutique gold standard. This guide ranks the top resorts by category so you can match your priorities to the right property.
Best Luxury Resorts
Top-tier properties with refined service, full amenities, and premium waterfront or garden settings.
Little Palm Island Resort & Spa
Ultra-luxury private island, boat/seaplane access only, Relais & Châteaux
Lower KeysBest Boutique Hotels
Small-scale historic inns, garden compounds, and intimate guesthouses with personal character.
Best Beach Resorts
Properties with direct beach access — rare and valuable in the Florida Keys.
Best Marina Resorts
Waterfront properties with on-site marinas, boat slips, and direct water access.
Best Family Resorts
Kid-friendly properties with pools, activities, and family-size accommodations.
Best Adults-Only Resorts
Properties restricted to adult guests — ideal for couples and romance.
Little Palm Island
Private island, thatched-roof bungalows, boat access only, $2,500+/night
Lower KeysFrequently Asked Questions
What is the best resort in the Florida Keys?
For luxury, Little Palm Island (Lower Keys) is in a class of its own — a private island with Relais & Châteaux service. For the best overall experience with beach, pools, and dining, Isla Bella (Marathon) and Cheeca Lodge (Islamorada) stand out. For boutique charm, The Gardens Hotel (Key West) is unmatched.
Which Florida Key has the best resorts?
Key West has the most resorts and the widest variety — from harbor-front luxury to boutique garden inns. Marathon has the best family resorts. Islamorada has the strongest sportfishing and boutique luxury options. Key Largo leads for dive-focused stays.
Are there all-inclusive resorts in the Florida Keys?
True all-inclusive resorts are rare in the Keys. Little Palm Island is the closest — room rates include breakfast, lunch, dinner, and many activities. Most Keys resorts operate on a room-only or bed-and-breakfast model.
What is the most affordable resort in the Florida Keys?
Marathon and Key Largo tend to have the most affordable options. Hyatt Place Marathon, Courtyard Key Largo, and Captain Pip's Marina Hideaway offer solid quality at lower price points. Off-season (September–November) rates can be 30–50% lower everywhere.
Which resort has the best beach in the Florida Keys?
Isla Bella Beach Resort (Marathon) has the best private resort beach — a sand beach on its own 24-acre island. Casa Marina Key West has Key West's largest private beach at 1,100 feet. Cheeca Lodge has the best resort beach in Islamorada.
Are there pet-friendly resorts in the Florida Keys?
Several resorts allow pets, including Parrot Key Hotel & Villas (Key West), Hawks Cay Resort (Marathon), and Courtney's Place (Key West). Policies and fees vary — always confirm with the property before booking.